Each one of these has its own advantages and disadvantages that we list in the following table:
A simple reading of the above table shows that the disadvantages of each technique are compensated by the advantages of the other.
Here comes the utility and the originality of the Time frequency representation, it combines the time waveform and the spectral representations and thus eliminates all the disadvantages.
The challenge is a competition between time waveform, spectral, and Time Frequency representations to recognize a combination of 4 numbers typed on a telephone keypad.
The frequency representation allows us to pinpoint the frequencies containing the energy of the signal - recognize the used keys, while the time waveform representation gives us the time duration of each event (0.2s).
The time-frequency spectrogram combines these two points in the following table:
The spectrogram in this case is the only technique understanding the reality of the phenomenon.
Original Signal measured on a bearing with an outer ring defect BPFO= 96.4Hz